Ask Me a Question


The truth is…

According to Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised 12th Edition the following information indicated by the section symbol “§” is true unless the organization has adopted a rule to the contrary.

§4:11 A second implies that the seconder agrees the motion should come before the meeting and not that they favor the motion. A member may second a motion to see the assembly go on record rejecting the proposal…

§4:3 After debate begins or any member voted, the lack of a second becomes immaterial and it is too late to make a point of order the motion is not seconded.

§4:11 Motions listed as requiring a second do not need to be seconded when made by direction of a board or committee.

§4:12 If the chair is certain a motion meets with wide approval, but members are slow in seconding it, the chair can state the question without waiting for a second.

§4:13 In handling routine motions, less attention is paid to the requirements of a second. If the chair is certain that a motion meets with wide approval, but members are slow in seconding it, the chair state the question without waiting for a second.

§4:14 For lists of certain parliamentary motions that do not require a second, see pages t44–t45.

§5:6 …most of the motions in this latter group do not require a second (see pages t44–t45).

§4:13 If a motion is considered and adopted without having been seconded—even in a case where there was no reason for the chair to overlook this requirement—the absence of a second does not affect the validity of the motion's adoption.

§12:91 Regardless of whether the maker of the main motion "accepts" the amendment, it must be opened to debate and voted on formally and is handled under the same rules as amendments generally.

§4:19 After the question has been stated by the chair, the motion becomes the property of the assembly, and its maker can do neither of these things without the assembly's consent…

§17:1 This motion is commonly misused in ordinary assemblies—in place of the motion to Postpone Indefinitely, to Postpone to a Certain Time, or other motions.

§17:14 It is out of order to move to lay a pending question on the table if there is evidently no other matter requiring immediate attention.

§17:15 The motion to Lay on the Table is often incorrectly used and wrongly admitted as in order with the intention of either killing an embarrassing question without a direct vote, or of suppressing a question without debate. The first of these two uses is unsafe if there is any contest on the issue; the second is in violation of a basic principle of general parliamentary law that only a two-thirds vote can rightfully suppress a main question without allowing free debate.

§21:15 When it appears that there is no further business in a meeting of an ordinary local society that normally goes through a complete order of business at each regular meeting, the chair, instead of waiting or calling for a motion to adjourn, can ask, "Is there any further business?" If there is no response, the chair can then say, "Since there is no further business, the meeting is adjourned."
§40:6 If a quorum fails to appear at a meeting, the inability to transact business does not detract from the fact that the rules requiring the meeting to be held were complied with and the meeting convened, even though it adjourned immediately.
§41:13 …the chair calls only on those who have reports to make…
§41:24 The chair should not announce the heading of Unfinished Business and General Orders unless the minutes show that there is some business to come up under it. In the latter case, he should have all such subjects listed in correct sequence in a memorandum prepared in advance of the meeting. He should not ask, "Is there any unfinished business?" but should state the question on the first item of business that is due to come up under this heading; and when it has been disposed of, he should proceed through the remaining subjects in their proper order.
§44:1 The word majority means "more than half"; and when the term majority vote is used without qualification—as in the case of the basic requirement—it means more than half of the votes cast by persons entitled to vote, excluding blanks or abstentions, at a regular or properly called meeting.
§44:11 A plurality vote is the largest number of votes to be given any candidate or proposition when three or more choices are possible; the candidate or proposition receiving the largest number of votes has a plurality. A plurality that is not a majority never chooses a proposition or elects anyone to office…
§44:12 On a tie vote, a motion requiring a majority vote for adoption is lost, since a tie vote is not a majority.
§44:13 …the chair calls only on those who have reports to make…
§45:32 All ballots that indicate a preference—provided they have been cast by persons entitled to vote—are considered in determining the number of votes cast for purposes of computing the majority.
§46:7 The same person can be nominated for more than one office, even if voting takes place at the same time on a single ballot.
§46:12 46:12 Members of the nominating committee are not barred from becoming nominees for office themselves.
46:31(1). …In such a case, if the person elected to two or more offices is present, that person can choose which of the offices they will accept.
§46:47 An officer-elect takes possession of office immediately upon their election’s becoming final unless the bylaws or other rules specify a later time. If a formal installation ceremony is prescribed, failure to hold it does not affect the time at which the new officers assume office.
§47:10 The chair should not hesitate to put the question on a motion to elect officers or appoint delegates or a committee even if he is included.
§48:5 The name of the seconder of a motion should not be entered in the minutes…
§48:11 A motion to “dispense with the reading of the minutes’ is not a request to omit their reading altogether.
§48:24 No action of acceptance by the assembly is required—or proper—on a financial report… it is the auditor’s report that the assembly accepts.
§51:15 A common error is to move that a report “be received” after it has been read… In fact, this motion is meaningless, since the report has already been received.

There is no such requirement in Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised.

If someone alleges there is such a rule have them state the rule, by giving the section and paragraph number to verify the rule.

There is no “three reading” requirement in Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised.

There is in the Standing Rules of the Senate of the U. S., Rule Number 14, clause 2.

There is in the Rules of the House of Representatives of the U.S., Rule XVI, clause 8.

There is in Mason’s Manual of Legislative Procedure, §720, p. 490.